Schrock v. Learning Curve Int’l, No. 08-1296, 2009 WL 3644331(7th Cir. Nov. 5, 2009).

The Seventh Circuit reversed and remanded Judge Shadur’s decision in this copyright case.*  The Court held that plaintiff’s photographs of defendant’s Thomas the Tank Engine trains were derivative works, and that absent a contractual provision to the contrary, plaintiff had a copyright in the derivative work.  Because plaintiff had permission to create the derivate works, plaintiff had a copyright in his derivative works.  And the Court could not decide whether the agreements prevented plaintiff from getting a copyright in the derivative work because the agreements were not part of the appellate record.  Additionally, the Court pointed out that the requirement that a derivative work be "substantially different" from the original did not create a heightened originality standard for derivative works.  The Court noted that plaintiff’s photographs of defendant’s Thomas the Tank engines had sufficient originality.

Click here for more about this case in the Blog’s archives.