IP News Shorts

Here are several stories and updates, as well as a new IP blog:

  • At Patently-O, Dennis Crouch covers the Federal Circuit decision in the appeal from the Northern District of Illinois case SourceOne Global Partners, LLC v. KGK Synergize, Inc. -- Click here for Crouch's post on the appeal and here for my post on the underlying decision.
     
  • The latest installment of Doug Lichtman's IP Colloquium is available -- click here to listen.  Lichtman and his guests from Microsoft, Paramount Pictures and MySpace discuss the protection of content in the digital age.  As always, it is an excellent listen and CLE credit is available.
     
  • Seattle Trademark Lawyer Michael Atkins has another great post up about Olympic trademarks, this time featuring an article that ran in the Chicago Tribune (here) and LA Times (here) quoting both Atkins and me.
     
  • California attorney and mediator Erica Bristol has started the IP Watchtower blog.  The blog covers all facets of intellectual property and the initial posts suggest it will be a great read.  I have added it to my feed reader.

 

IP News Shorts

Here are several stories that I have been wanting to blog about, but have not been able to get to because of the new Local Patent Rules, my webinar on reducing IP litigation costs (I was glad to see that so many of you attended and found the presentation valuable) and pressing client matters:

  • Judge Zagel was interviewed by Metropolitan Corporate Counsel.  He discussed how his docket has been impacted by the recession and  noted, among other things, that parties have been much more interested in and willing to agree to staying cases or slow discovery -- click here to read the story.  He also briefly discusses discovery of electronically stored information.
     
  • Seattle Trademark Lawyer Michael Atkins has an excellent series of posts on the US Olympic Committee's enforcement of the Olympic marks, to which it has almost absolute rights based upon federal law -- click here, here, here, here and here.  I had planned to write about these issues myself early this week while Chicago enjoyed winning the 2016 Summer Olympics, but as you all likely know by now that is not quite how the vote went.

IP News Shorts

Here are a few stories from the blogosphere that I did not have time to fully cover this week because of pressing client matters and some new opportunities:

  • The Federalist Society is offering an excellent podcast discussing Bilski from almost every possible angle.  The podcast features West Virginia University Law Professor Michael Risch and American University Law Professor Joshua Sarnoff, who filed competing amicus briefs.  The podcast is a half-hour well spent for  anyone involved in patent law.  Click here to listen to the podcast.  Hat tip to Duncan Bucknell at the IP Think Tank Blog for pointing out the podcast.
     
  • Doug Lichtman's IP Colloquium takes a thorough look at the copyright issue of the year thus far, Shepard Fairey's iconic Obama image, and Lichtman offers free CLE credit for listening.  Click here for that edition and here for the IP Colloquium's archives.
     
  • Michael Atkins has identified the top five trademark cases of the last year at the Seattle Trademark Lawyer.  Number 4 is the Seventh Circuit's decision in AutoZone v. StrickClick here for more on the district court decisions in the case from the Blog's archives.  This is what Atkins had to say about the Seventh Circuit's decision:

[G]ood likelihood of confusion analysis in reversal of hard-fought trademark infringement case, which also was one of the first dilution cases under the [Trademark Dilution Revision Act].

 

 

Blawg Review #225: A Trademark Focus from Pike Place Market

Seattle Trademark Lawyer Michael Atkins did a superb job hosting this week's Blawg Review -- click here to read it.  Atkins takes a stroll through Seattle's famous Pike's Place Market looking at Seattle-based blogs -- Washington State Patent Law Blog, LexBlog and the China Law Blog, among others -- as well as a number of trademark blogs.  I was fortunate to be featured on Atkins's tour with last week's post about the Lettuce trademark dispute -- click here to read my post.  Thanks Mike, for a great Blawg Review and for including the Blog.

IP News Shorts

Here are several stories and updates worth a read:

  • I am hosting the August Carnival of Trust on Monday, August 3 here.  I hosted once before and really enjoyed the experience -- click here and here.   The Carnival of Trust is a monthly, traveling review of ten of the last month's best posts related to various aspects of trust in the business world.  If you have trust-related posts from the last month, send them to me. by Friday or Saturday.  For other examples of Carnival of Trust posts, check out recent hosts Adrian Dayton and Victoria Pynchon.
     
  • I was featured in Stephanie Allen West's Reading Minds column in the ABA's Law Practice Management magazine this month -- click here to read the column.  Along with Jennifer Loud Ungar, Andrew Flusche, and Todd Kashdan, I was asked to recommend a favorite management book.  I went with an unorthodox choice, but a valuable read, the Boy Scout Patrol Leader's Handbook.  Here is some of my recommendation:

In the many years since I relied on the Handbook to run Boy Scout patrols, I have found the lessons in this volume to be equally applicable to leading and managing teams of lawyers or businesspeople. The Handbook is a powerful guide for developing successful organizations, maintaining group morale and achieving group success. As an example, it lists these 10 tips for being a good leader: (1) keep your word; (2) be fair; (3) communicate well and often; (4) be flexible; (5) be organized; (6) delegate; (7) set an example; (8) be consistent; (9) give praise; and (10) ask for help. These are words to live by for patrol leaders, lawyers and C-level executives alike.

 

Copyright & Trademark News

I have noticed that my news updates tend to be patent-focused, so today  they focus on trademarks and copyrights:

  • IP Law & Business (subscription required to access the article) has an interesting article in the February/March 2009 issue identifying Justice Ginsburg as the Supreme Court's "champion of copyright holders" because of recent opinions supporting broader copyrights.  The article also identifies Justice Breyer, based on dissents in the same cases, as leading the cause for narrower copyrights.  And the article predicts that the Supreme Court is trending toward a narrower view of copyrights.
     
  • Seattle Trademark Lawyer Michael Atkins has a timely post (click here to read it) that traces the March Madness trademark back to the Illinois high school basketball playoffs, as early as the 1940s.  The NCAA and the Illinois High School Association have since pooled their rights and both have a license to use the marks. 
     
  • Victoria Pynchon has a great series of posts looking at laches in trademark law based upon a recent Ninth Circuit decision -- click here and here.

 

Legal News

Here is some IP-related news for your weekend enjoyment:

  • Seattle Trademark Lawyer Mike Graham warns that the excellent Stanford IP Clearinghouse may not be counting all cases in its data based on Graham's comparison of 2008 trademark filings in the Western District of Washington using PACER and the Stanford IP Clearinghouse -- click here to read the post.  I echo Graham's statement that even if there are discrepancies, or even missing data, the Stanford IP Clearinghouse is an excellent resource with vast potential.
     
  • Blawg Review #196 was hosted on Australia Day this week by Peter Black's Freedom to Differ, an Australian blog focused on internet regulation -- click here to read the Review.    After tackling controversy surrounding the date of Australia day, Black discusses several IP issues including Duncan Bucknell's post regarding YouTube copyright issues; and Brendan Scott's series on closed source software.

 

IP Licensing Best Practices

As I mentioned here, I recently gave a presentation for the National Constitution Center on settlement agreement best practices.  I focused on the important principles of:  knowing your client's and opponent's needs; generating trust between the parties during the negotiation and through any ongoing responsibilities pursuant to the agreement; bringing in experts on various topics; and making sure that your agreement and its terms had buy in from all relevant client stakeholders (not just legal, but accounting, media relations, tax and the appropriate C-level or business executives.  You can see a copy of the slides here.

Mike Graham, the Seattle Trademark Lawyer, is presenting soon on a related topic, except he is looking at planning ahead for potential litigation in trademark licensing.  It promises to be a very interesting presentation based on Graham's initial notes  -- click here to read them.  Just as litigators do well to bring in licensing experts to finalize settlement agreements, licensing attorneys do well to have a litigator's perspective on their agreements.

[UPDATE:]  I just learned that Seattle Trademark Lawyer (the blog, not Graham) turned two yesterday -- click here to read Graham's birthday post.  Congratulations Mike.  Two years of top quality content, and going strong.  I started this blog a few months before Graham started STL.  It is nice to see my contemporaries succeeding.

Blawg Review #173

Last week’s Olympic edition Blawg Review focused on the medals. Building on that, this week I discuss the elements of a world record swim. If you were watching last week, instead of blogging, you saw 20 of them in the Olympic pool; seven by Mr. Phelps.

 

Practice

Nothing is more critical than preparation. A big part of preparation is tightening your stroke and cutting out unnecessary motion. Reese Morrison, at the Law Department Management blog, discusses blunt suggestions for trimming legal bills.

 

Endless hours in the pool alone are not enough, you need a good coach. Business development coach Cordell Parvin provides an excellent three part series at his Law Consulting Blogone, two, and three – on persistence, an important element of any Olympic training program. In an Olympic caliber display of persistence, Drug & Device Law had an exhaustive post discussing and classifying each medical device preemption case since the landmark Supreme Court decision in Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc., 128 S. Ct. 999 (2008).

 

You also need a support network to help you get through all of the pool time. Bruce Allen, at Marketing Catalyst, teaches us how to avoid the cocktail conversation you cannot escape from at a networking event. At Copyblogger, John Morrow explains that content is no longer king in the blogosphere, you need friends. And he teaches you how to get them. At BlawgIT, Brett Trout – who is a fighter, not a swimmer – has an interesting post about how to work together as a community to thwart webjackings (the hijacking of a website). And Mediation Channel’s Diane Levin discusses the social side of blogging, and reading blogs.

 

Of course, if you do not have time to practice you will never set the record. So, you need a job, or at least some cash. On that note, Harmful Error posts the great news that loan forgiveness programs were expanded this week for legal aid lawyers, state prosecutors and public defenders. 

 

The Suit

The clothes make the man (or the woman). This year the go-to duds were Speedo’s LZR suits. Patent Librarian Michael White tells us that, no surprise, Speedo patented the LZRIPKat expands on swimming patents, providing a broader view of Olympics-related patents.

 

Genes


As a guy who swam for a lot of years and practiced hard throughout, I can tell you not everyone has what it takes to set world records. The closest I came was getting beat by an Olympian and world record holder. Of course, you might be less impressed by my loss if you knew that at the time his Olympic medals were four or five decades old, and I was 19. At Idealawg, Stephanie West Allen discusses the traits that make entrepreneurs entrepreneurial.

                                                                     Mental Focus

One of the big stories on Phelps this week was how he thinks of nothing but not losing during a race. At Litigation & Trial, Maxwell Kennerly tells us that you have to know when you are sweating the details more than your client would want by over emphasizing proof-reading. Of course, even Kennerly agrees that some details matter. 

                                                                  Knowing the Rules 

You have to know the rules. Turn wrong or break the rules for your stroke and beating a record by ten seconds will not matter. At the Legal Juice, John Mesirow reports that kids at the Lake County Florida library are allowed to rent R-rated movies because they believe it is an unconstitutional delegation of authority for the Motion Picture Association of America’s guidelines for determining obscenity. I am sure kids from all over that area are flocking to the Lake County library because the rules are on their side, at least for now.

 

Filewrapper reports on a Federal Circuit decision holding that copyright infringement, and not just breach of contract, when the terms of an open source license governing the copyrighted material are breached. For more on this major decision in the IP world, check out: BLT; Law Pundit; and Patently-O.

 

Seattle Trademark Lawyer Mike Graham shows the consequences of not following the rules using two Western District of Washington opinions.

 

Ethan Lieb, guest blogging at Freakonomics, argues that we need to change the rules requiring unanimous juries. And the WSJ Law Blog discusses a judge and a juror who clashed over jury nullification.

The Start


A bad start is hard to recover from, especially when you are chasing the fastest time ever. Evan Schaeffer shows how to open well at trial at the Illinois Trial Practice Weblog, and he links to Trial Theatre’s opening statement quiz.

Turns

Coming off the wall in a turn is the fastest a swimmer goes during a race. So, you need good turns. IntLawGrrls discuss how to turn around the conflict between Georgia and Russia (sorry the turns section was tough).

 

Legal Literacy discusses Whole Foods’ turned around (or recalled) beef and looks behind the scenes at how it happened and Whole Foods’ impressively quick response.

 

The Finish


Do you do an extra stroke or do you glide in hard? Always a tough question, but the .01 seconds the decision costs you can mean the race and the record.

At his E.D. Texas Weblog, Michael Smith reports that while the E.D. Texas started out as a rocket docket, particularly for patents, it has now slowed down and let many other districts catch it with a time to trial of 24 – 30 months.

 

The Law and Magic Blog reminds us that we cannot always win, and that trying to rig the system to guarantee wins – he is talking about the stock market, but it holds true for the pool – is dangerous work.

 

At the IP ADR Blog, Victoria Pynchon praises several Perkins Coie attorneys who went the distance for their pro bono clients at Gitmo and earned the clients’ respect for providing them an able defense.

 

** Images provided via a Creative Commons license by A. Dawson or Andre from Flicker. **

 

Next week's Blawg Review will be at fellow LexBlog site, the Texas Appellate Law Blog.

 

Blawg Review has information about next week's host, and instructions on how to get your blawg posts reviewed in upcoming issues.

 

 

IP Legal News

Here are several items that did not necessarily warrant a separate post, but are worth some attention:

  • Chicago blogger Evan Brown of Internet Cases recently participated in episode 16 of the This Week in the Law podcast with law blog luminaries Denise Howell (the host), Nicole Black, Marty Schwimmer and Ernie Svenson -- click here for Brown's post and a link to the podcast. Their lively discussion included numerous IP topics including: 
    • DMCA anticircumvention provisions;
    • ediscovery; and
    • the Viacom v. Google discovery issues (the parties ultimately agreed that the compelled user data could be produced anonymously).
  • Mike Atkins did a great series of post comparing the benefits of state and federal trademark registration -- click here and here for the posts.  These posts are a great primer, if you want to understand the differences between and trade offs for state versus federal registration.
  • The John Marshall Law School has been included in the PTO's new Law School Clinic Program.  Beginning this fall, second and third year John Marshall students will represent inventors in actual PTO proceedings.  This is a great opportunity for both the students and the inventors.  Click here for John Marshall's press release about the new program.

Should Apologies be Added to Trademark Damages?

Mike Atkins at the Seattle Trademark Lawyer has an interesting post -- click here for the post -- about a pending Chinese trademark infringement suit, in which plaintiff seeks monetary damages and a public apology to be published in newspapers.  IP Dragon follows up Atkins's post, explaining that an apology is a Chinese trademark remedy and that an apology is a punishment in a "face saving culture," as IP Dragon describes China and Japan, the nationalities of the two entities involved in the suit.  Click here for IP Dragon's post.

But punishment or not, this raises an interesting question for US trademark law.  It seems to me that a public apology (or acknowledgement of the infringement) would be a more powerful tool for the consumers that trademark law intends to protect than just monetary damages and an injunction.  An acknowledgement of the infringement would warn consumers who might still unwittingly purchase items based upon the infringing marks after the injunction is in place.  Maybe it is time to amend the Lanham Act.

 

Northern District's 2008 Trademark Infringment Filings Strong

The Northern District had 72 trademark cases filed during the first half of 2008.  That is well on the way to meeting or exceeding 2007's total of 138 cases -- click here to read about the 2007 case filings.  So, it looks like, as with patents, the Northern District continues to have an active trademark infringement docket.  A difficult economy is not slowing the Northern District's IP cases.

Thanks to Mike Atkins at the Seattle Trademark Lawyer for the idea of a mid-year status report.  Expect a similar copyright mid-year report shortly.

Northern District Continues as a Top Five Patent District

Patent Appeal Tracer has a great post listing the patent filings for June 2008 by district.  Tracer used Pacer and "math" to come up with its list, which shows that the Northern District is fourth in patent filings for the month with 19 of 255 filings (about 85 of the total).  Those 19 filings give the Northern District 87 patent cases in the first half of 2008, well on the way to another busy year.  The top three were not surprising:
  1. Eastern District of Texas -- 32 filings
  2. District of Delaware -- 24 filings
  3. Central District of California -- 20 filings

Patent Appeal Tracer also mentions EZ4Media's two Northern District cases against thirteen defendants as cases to watch.  The defendants in those cases are alleged to infringe patents to wireless streaming of digital media.

[UPDATE:] More on the year's trademark and copyright filings is coming next week, prompted by Mike Graham's Seattle Trademark Lawyer post about this year's Western District of Washington trademark litigation statistics -- click here to read it.  Thanks for the mention Mike.

Blawg Review #162

Blawg Review #162 is now available at the China Law Blog.  This week's review is a bit light on IP links, except for Mike Atkin's Seattle Trademark Lawyer post detailing a potential trademark dispute involving coffee and roller derby -- click here for the post.  Despite that (or maybe because of it), it is a great read.  And if you are looking for good information on Chinese business law, the China Law Blog is one of the best.

More Regional Blog Updates

Shortly after my Friday post updating the list of regional IP blogs, Mark Walters, of the Washington State Patent Law Blog, pointed out that I had left him off the list.  The mistake was unintentional and I have remedied it in the original post and the list that follows this paragraph.  In the process of gathering links to revise my list, I came across the Georgia Patent Law Blog in the Washington State Patent Law Blog's blogroll.  So, now I have two blogs to update:

Australian Trademarks Law Blog*

Canadian Trademark Blog

Delaware IP Law Blog

E. D. Texas Blog

Florida IP Blog*

Georgia Patent Law Blog (N.D. Georgia)

Illinois Trial Pratice Weblog (okay, it is not IP specific, but it is regional and provides excellent content)

IP Dragon(China) 

IP Legal Lounge

Las Vegas Trademark Attorney

Los Angeles Intellectual Property Trademark Attorney Blog

Maryland Intellectual Property Law Blog*

Patent Trademark Blog(some Orange County focus) 

Seattle Trademark Lawyer Blog

Tech Law Forum Blog (N.D. Cal.)

Washington State Patent Law Blog

If you know of other regional IP blogs, post a comment or send me an email and I will add them to the list. 

*These are blogs developed and hosted by LexBlog just like this Blog.

New Regional IP Blogs

Since my last post listing the Blog's "cousin" blogs -- regional IP blogs – another has joined the family. The Los Angeles Intellectual Property Trademark Attorney Blog, published by Milord & Associates.  Welcome to the family. Here is the revised list:

 

Australian Trademarks Law Blog*

Canadian Trademark Blog

Delaware IP Law Blog

E. D. Texas Blog

Florida IP Blog*

Georgia Patent Law Blog (N.D. Georgia)

Illinois Trial Pratice Weblog (okay, it is not IP specific, but it is regional and provides excellent content)

IP Dragon(China) 

IP Legal Lounge

Las Vegas Trademark Attorney

Los Angeles Intellectual Property Trademark Attorney Blog

Maryland Intellectual Property Law Blog*

Patent Trademark Blog(some Orange County focus) 

Seattle Trademark Lawyer Blog

Tech Law Forum Blog (N.D. Cal.)

Washington State Patent Law Blog

[UPDATE]:  I was quickly reminded that I forgot the excellent Washington State Patent Law Blog, which has been added to this post, and in that process I discovered the Georgia Patent Law Blog, also added, thanks to Mark Walter's (Washington State Patent Law Blog) blog roll.

If you know of other regional IP blogs, post a comment or send me an email and I will add them to the list.  A hat tip to Mike Atkins for pointing out the new blog at his Seattle Trademark Lawyer blog.

*These are blogs developed and hosted by LexBlog just like this Blog.

IP News Roundup

Several unrelated legal stories that are worth a read:

  • An excellent Illinois Business Law Journal article regarding whether Google is losing its trademark to genericide.  It concludes that Google's mark is relatively safe, partly because Google's trademark is identical to its domain name.*
  • Patent Troll Tracker has been unmasked.  The unmasking was based, at least in part, on Ray Niro's bounty for Troll Tracker's name.  As would be expected, Troll Tracker unmasked himself with class and a sense of humor.  He is taking a few weeks off from blogging to decide whether to continue.  I hope he decides to continue.  Troll Tracker is a powerful voice on some complex issues, and he is right that it is great to see another inhouse legal blogger.  Plus, it would be a shame for Troll Tracker to disappear just after Ron Coleman finally discovered him. 
  • Blawg Review #148 is up at Blawg IT.  In addition to the usual links to law blog posts, Brett helps us smell the electronic roses with numerous non-legal video clips.

*  Hat tip to Michael Atkins at the Seattle Trademark Blog for pointing out the article during his Trademark Dilution Weekend.

A Look at the Trademark Dilution Revision Act of 2006

Congress enacted the Trademark Dilution Revision Act (the "TDRA") about one year ago in an effort to resolve numerous open trademark issue.*  Many believe that the TDRA has opened more questions than it answered.  The University of Michigan Law Review's First Impressions blog recently addressed those issues with a series of articles:

*  For more on the TDRA, click here for the Blog's archives and click here for the Seattle Trademark Lawyer’s coverage of the TDRA's first anniversary.

A New Regional Patent Blog for Washington State

 

 

Since my last post listing the Blog's "cousin" blogs -- regional IP blogs – several have joined the family. The Washington State Patent Law Blog and the Las Vegas Trademark Attorney have both started in the last several months. Welcome to the family. Here is the revised list:

Delaware IP Law Blog

E. D. Texas Blog

Florida IP Blog*

Illinois Trial Pratice Weblog (okay, it is not IP specific, but it is regional and provides excellent content)

IP Dragon(China) 

IP Legal Lounge

Las Vegas Trademark Attorney

Maryland Intellectual Property Law Blog

Patent Trademark Blog(some Orange County focus) 

Seattle Trademark Lawyer Blog

Tech Law Forum Blog (N.D. Cal.)

If you know of other regional IP blogs, post a comment or send me an email (david.donoghue@dlapiper.com) and I will add them to the list.

*The Florida IP Blog is another blog developed and hosted by LexBlog just like this Blog and, as usual, it is a great looking site with easy navigation.

Changed Circumstances Warrant Dismissal With Costs, Not Attorney's Fees

Milwaukee Elec. Tool Corp. v. Robert Bosch Tool Corp., No. 05 C 1171, 2007 WL 2875232 (N.D. Ill. Sep. 28, 2004) (Kendall, J.)

Judge Kendall granted plaintiff’s motion to dismiss its Lanham Act case with prejudice and awarded defendant its costs but not its fees pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a). The Court held that attorney’s fees were not warranted because the case and its dismissal after substantial fact discovery were not exceptional. Plaintiff dismissed its case because of two significant events which plaintiff believed reduced its likelihood of success.

            First, during discovery Congress passed the Trademark Dilution Revision Act (“TDRA”)* which changed the definition of “famous” such that fame within a niche market was no longer sufficient for dilution. Plaintiff was not certain it could prove fame outside its market. Second, defendant changed the trade dress, and particularly the color scheme, of its accused SKIL line of power tools. Plaintiff believed that defendant’s new trade dress was less similar to plaintiff’s and, therefore, plaintiff’s case was more difficult to prove. The Court accepted plaintiff’s reasoning and, therefore, held that the case was not exceptional. The Court did, however, award costs, which plaintiff had originally agreed it would pay.

* For more on the TDRA, click here for the Seattle Trademark Lawyer’s coverage of the TDRA this week in honor of the TDRA’s first anniversary.

Ronald Beats Mickey: Northern District Home to Several Top Global Brands

According to Interbrand Ronald is worth more than Mickey.  Interbrand has just published its 2007 Best Global Brands, ranking the top 100 brands that:  1) derive at least a third of earnings outside of the brand’s home country; 2) are recognized beyond the brand's customer base; and 3) have public marketing and financial data.  Interbrand also excludes brands that are hard to identify as having brand value separate from their products or services. For example, pharma brands are excluded because Interbrand has determined that consumers focus on products rather than the overarching company branding. That leaves Northern District companies like Abbott Labs out of the running.  But the Northern District is still very well represented.  For example, McDonald's jumped one spot this year, surpassing Disney in brand value.  Here are the Northern District companies (or at least those very near the Northern District) on the list:

Northern District Top Global Brands
07 Rank 06 Rank Company 07 Brand Value (in USD Millions)
8 9 McDonald's 29.398
59 59 Wrigley's 5.777
77 69 Motorola 4.149
86 79 Kraft 3.732
       

Thanks to the Seattle Trademark Lawyer for identifying the ranking.

Taking IP Defense to the Court of Public Opinion

The Wall Street Journal print edition had an interesting article about a new trend in defending lawsuits that focused on an IP dispute -- A Growing Dispute:  Fertilizer Start-Up Uses Web as Defense (subscription required).  The article discusses TerraCycle Inc.'s use of a website (www.suedbyscotts.com) to bolster its defense of a lawsuit Scotts Miracle-Gro Co. filed against TerraCycle alleging trade dress infringement and false advertising.*  According to the article, TerraCycle has not raised much money from its online solicitation for defense fund donations.  But during the first four weeks of its online defense, TerraCycle's sales jumped 122%, as opposed to 31% during the same period last year.  TerraCycle also saw a corresponding spike in visits to its primary website.  The WSJ Law Blog picked up on the story and developed it further, identifying several other defendants that have used websites as an aspect of their defense strategies, including Vonage's site (www.freetocompete.com) developed in connection with its prominent patent dispute.

It appears that defending cases on the internet is a growing trend.  I doubt it will benefit defendants within the confines of the courtroom or the legal proceedings generally.  Perhaps bringing details of the suit into the public eye will help identify additional prior art or apply pressure from interest groups like consumers or shareholders to get plaintiffs to change tactics.  But it seems to me that the biggest benefit of these sites may commercial, they make news and drive additional traffic to the defendant's primary site.

* You can read more about the Scotts Miracle-Gro v. TerraCycle dispute at the Seattle Trademark Lawyer.

A New Regional IP Blog for the N.D. Cal.

Since my last post listing the Blog's "cousin" blogs -- regional IP blogs -- another has joined the family.  The Tech Law Forum Blog has switched its format to focus on N.D. California IP cases.  Welcome to the family.  Here is the revised list:
 
 
 
Illinois Trial Pratice Weblog (okay, it is not IP specific, but it is regional and provides excellent content)
IP Dragon (China)
 
 
Patent Trademark Blog (some Orange County focus)

Tech Law Forum Blog (N.D. Cal.)

If you know of other regional IP blogs, post a comment or send me an email (david.donoghue@dlapiper.com) and I will add them to the list.

*The Florida IP Blog is another blog developed and hosted by LexBlog just like this Blog and, as usual, it is a great looking site with easy navigation.