Chicago IP Attorney & Lawyer : R. David Donoghue : Chicago IP Litigation Blog

Chief Judge Holderman recently gave the annual State of the Court address, concluding that the Northern District continues to be an active, growing district court. Civil case filings were up 6.2% from 2008 to 2009, and the Northern District remains in the top 10% of district courts for median time to disposition – 6.2 months. 

The Court began 2009 with one vacant judgeship – created by Judge Filip's March 2008 resignation. The Court ended 2009 with from after Judges Bucklo, Coar and Gettleman took senior status. In February 2010, Judge Manning also took senior status. Judge Feinerman was confirmed last month, reducing the vacant seats by one, but there could be five vacancies again at the end of July when Judge Anderson retires. 

The magistrate bench was also active. Judges Ashman and Keys shifted to recalled status. Judges Finnegan, Gilbert and Kim joined the bench. 

Finally, the number of registered e-filers is up 18% to over 25,000. And the daily filing rate is up 15% to an average 867 documents per day. 

• Email This
• Print
• Trackbacks
• Share Link

Chief Judge Holderman recently gave his annual State of the Northern District speech.  In a word, Judge Holderman said that the state of the District is "good."  Here are some of the highlights of the presentation (click here to read the Court's press release):

• Judge Gettleman intends to take senior status May 5 and Judge Coar intends to take senior status August 12.  Additionally, Magistrate Judge Ashman intends to retire later this year.
   
• Combined with the vacancy created when Judge Filip went to the Justice Department, when Judges Gettleman and Coar take senior status there will be three Article III and one magistrate vacancies on the Court.
   
• Civil filings were up 2.7% in 2008 over 2007.  And the Court resolves those disputes quickly.  The Northern District is in the top 10% of district court with its median time of 6.2 months to disposition.
   
• The Court is participating in a pilot program which allows jurors to fill out jury forms and get information about their service online.

• Email This
• Print
• Trackbacks
• Share Link

According to Chief Judge Holderman during the annual state of the Northern District speech, the state of the Northern District is "good" -- click here for the Northern District's statement regarding the speech.  The Northern District was briefly at full capacity, between Judge Dow's appointment to the Northern District and Judge Filip's resignation to join the Department of Justice.  Other highlights of the presentation included:

• The Northern District remains in the top ten districts in terms of median time to civil case disposition at 6.2 months.
  
• Magistrate Judges Brown and Mahoney were reappointed to additional eight year terms; and
  
• The Northern District's 2007 civil case load remained nearly constant, falling only .5% from its 2006 level.

The Northern District's steady civil case load is especially impressive in light of the Seventh Circuit's reduced case load in 2007.  The Chicago Tribune's Ameet Sachdev reported -- click here for the story -- that the Seventh Circuit's Chief Judge Easterbrook, during his state of the Seventh Circuit speech, reported that the Seventh Circuit's case load dropped 10% for the second year in a row.  Sachdev noted that federal appellate court case loads had averaged a 5% drop per year since 2000.  And Easterbrook explained the Seventh Circuit's 10% drop for 2007 as based upon two primary factors:

• The Seventh Circuit's district courts saw an overall 6% drop in their case loads; and
  
• The Seventh Circuit's preference for bright line rules over totality of the circumstance tests made it easier for entities to settle their disputes, saying:

Rules make it easier for private parties to avoid litigation, or settle their disputes, without asking for appellate evaluation in every case.

• Email This
• Print
• Trackbacks
• Share Link

Last week Chief Judge Holderman delivered the annual State of the Court Address, it was his first after becoming Chief Judge last summer.  According to the Chicago Daily Law Bulletin (subscription required) he explained that the Northern District was doing very well and touched on, among others, the following subjects:

• By the end of 2007, parties should be able to file complaints and pay filing fees electronically.
  
• The Northern District plans to update its website later this year.  To that end, anyone with an e-filing account should expect a letter from Judge Holderman this fall soliciting suggestions to improve the website -- www.ilnd.uscourts.gov.
  
• The Northern District's filings were down slightly from 2005 (7,606 cases filed in 2006 compared to 7,805 in 2005).  But if student loan and mortgage foreclosure actions are removed, filings jumped 17% from 2005 to 2006.
  
• The Northern District is the seventh fastest district court based upon the time from filing to disposition of civil cases -- 6.5 months.
  
• The Northern District has instituted criminal background checks of prospective jurors, after three jurors in former Governor Ryan's 2006 criminal trial failed to disclose their criminal records or arrests during the jury selection process.

You can also read the Northern District's summary of the speech here.

• Email This
• Print
• Trackbacks
• Share Link