Santana Tesoro, LLC v. The P’ships Identified on Schedule A, No. 26 C 1395, (N.D. Ill. Aug. 28, 2026) (Gettleman, J.).
Judge Gettleman, in this Schedule A case, denied plaintiff Santana Tesoro’s motion for default judgment against the China-based defendants, holding that their addresses were known and, therefore, the Hague Convention applied. The Court granted default judgment only as to five defendants with United States addresses, which are not subject to the Hague Convention.
Santana Tesoro submitted an “Address Verification Results” exhibit listing an address for each defendant, while arguing that none of the addresses were known because none could be verified against public and paid resources. The Court found that argument made no sense from a common-sense standpoint. The Court traced the problem to the words “and verify” in NBA Properties, 549 F. Supp. 3d 790 (N.D. Ill. 2021), which plaintiffs have used to recast known addresses as unknown ones. In the Court’s view, the reasonable diligence standard, designed to keep plaintiffs from escaping the Hague Convention, had been distorted into a device for doing just that.
Of particular interest, the Court held:
- The Court provided a fairly detailed history of Schedule A litigation in the Northern District at the outset of the opinion that is a useful primer for anyone new to the state of Schedule A litigation anywhere but particularly in the Northern District.
- There is no burden on plaintiffs to verify each defendant’s address. When a plaintiff has address information, the Court will presume the address is known for purposes of the Hague Convention.
- The reasonable diligence standard applies only when a plaintiff asserts that it has no address information for a defendant.
- Reading “not known” in Article 1 to include addresses that cannot be verified by a second, independent source lacks textual support and frustrates the Convention’s purpose. The Convention entrusts each signatory’s central authority, not U.S. courts acting ex parte, with delivering documents to foreign addresses. The Court noted that it was ill-equipped to evaluate verification efforts concerning addresses in China.
- The Convention’s negotiating history confirms that the drafters separated unknown addresses from incorrect addresses, and the “not known” provision addressed only the former. Interestingly, the Court noted that it used Claude and Google Translate to translate that history, which was published only in French.
The Court acknowledged the practical difficulties and expressed little sympathy for most Schedule A defendants. But it noted that Article 15 permits default judgment six months after service documents are transmitted, that asset restraints give defendants little reason to hide, and that plaintiffs remain free to contact defendants through other means. Because Santana Tesoro had not transmitted service documents by a method the Convention provides, default judgment against the foreign defendants was denied.
This is a significant opinion for Schedule A practitioners. If other judges follow it, plaintiffs that possess addresses for foreign defendants will need to serve through the Hague Convention before obtaining default judgment.

